Commentary on the Advert & Its Narrative
Narrative Structure & Emotional Contrast
- The advert (“Earworm”) opens with a schoolboy joyfully singing Total Eclipse of the Heart as acapella — no backing track, just his voice. At first, it feels playful and innocent — a child simply humming a tune he likes, reinforcing childhood purity and wonder.
- Revelation & Metaphor
As the story unfolds, we learn that his mother is on the phone trying to get through to a housing or accommodation service — and the same song is playing on a loop as hold music. The earworm (a song stuck in your head) becomes a powerful metaphor: what’s in his head is exactly what she’s enduring in real life — waiting, hoping, being stuck. - Creative Choices
- A cappella singing: They deliberately chose for the boy’s voice to be unaccompanied to feel raw and real.
- Involvement of lived experience: Shelter and the agency worked with families who have lived in temporary accommodation to shape the portrayal authentically.
- Emotional Payoff
The use of the twist that the song he’s been joyfully singing is actually the looped hold tone his mother is stuck on portrays heartbreak. It drives home how deep and personal the struggle of being homeless or in insecure accommodation really is. It’s not a “look how sad” ad, instead it’s subtle and deeply empathetic.
How It Reflects Altruism & Prosocial Behaviour
- Empathy Building; By showing the child’s innocent joy and then revealing the emotional burden behind it, the ad makes viewers feel the worry, frustration, and helplessness. That empathy can motivate people to help.
- Raising Awareness; The ad illuminates a less-visible crisis: families in temporary accommodation. Many people may not realise that hold music on the phone is something that some parents literally live with while trying to secure stable housing.
- Call to Action
- Shelter’s campaign isn’t just about sharing a story — it encourages donations, support, and a sense that we (society) must act. When viewers connect emotionally, they’re more likely to contribute or get involved.
- Solidarity & Shared Responsibility
- The advert suggests that no family should be left on hold — literally or metaphorically. It frames homelessness not just as an individual misfortune, but a systemic issue where society must step in.
- Altruistic Behavior Encouraged
- For many viewers, reacting to this campaign (by donating or advocating) is an altruistic act: helping families they will likely never meet, for a cause that is deeply meaningful but not always visible.
No comments:
Post a Comment